Response to Disappointed with Bob Dylon

I really don't understand what you are saying here. I have no idea whether Bob Dylan is Jewish or not. I don't care whether Bob Dylan is Jewish or not. My point, I thought, was clear. Your comments imply that Bob Dylan must be for the war because he is Jewish. Not only is this a spurious argument, but it is a dangerous generalisation. *If* he is pro-Iraq war (and lack of speaking out doesn't necessarily make it so), then being American and white and a man are factors which are more likely to weight the scales---*if* we were to make dangerous generalisations about him and those groups.

Created By: Mollie Huggins